Benign and malignant characteristics of breast lesions at ultrasound
Last revised by Andrew Murphy ◉ on 27 Sep 2021
Citation, DOI & article data
Citation:
Gaillard, F., Murphy, A. Benign and malignant characteristics of breast lesions at ultrasound. Reference article, Radiopaedia.org. (accessed on 26 Jun 2022) https://doi.org/10.53347/rID-1014
Permalink:
rID:
1014
Article created:
Revisions:
39 times by 15 users - see full revision history
Sections:
-
Tag:
Synonyms:
- Breast lesions - ultrasound
- Breast ultrasound features: benign vs malignant
- Ultrasound characterisation of breast lesions
- Ultrasound characterization of breast lesions
- Ultrasound characteristics of benign breast lesions
- Ultrasound characteristics of malignant breast lesions
Benign and malignant characteristics of breast lesions at ultrasound allow the classification as either malignant, intermediate or benign based on work published by Stavros et al. in 1995.
Radiographic features
Ultrasound
Malignant characteristics (with positive predictive values)
-
sonographic spiculation: 87-90% 1,4
- alternate hypo-hyperechoic lines radiating perpendicularly from surface of nodules (if lesion is surrounded by echogenic tissue, hypoechoic strands will be seen; if lesion is surrounded by fat, echogenic strands may be seen)
- deeper (taller) than wide: 74-80% 1,4
- except in certain grade III Invasive ductal carcinomas
-
microlobulations: 75%
- small lobulations 1-2 mm on the surface; risk of malignancy rises with increasing numbers
- thick hyperechoic halo: 74%
- angular margins: 70%
- markedly hypoechoic nodule: 70%
- sonographic posterior acoustic shadowing: 50%
- branching pattern: 30%
- multiple projections from the nodule within or around ducts extending away from the nipple, usually seen in larger tumors
- punctate calcifications: 25%
- which usually do not shadow
- duct extension: 25%
- is seen as projection from a nodule which extends radially within or around a duct towards the nipple
- heterogeneous echotexture 3
- compressibility
- in general terms, benign lesions compress with transducer pressure and malignant lesions displace the breast tissue without changing in height; this is the basis for elastography
Benign characteristics (with negative predictive values)
- well circumscribed, hyperechoic tissue: ~100%
- wider than deep: 99%
- gently curving smooth lobulations (<3 in a wider than deep nodule, i.e. D/W ratio <1): 99%
- thin echogenic pseudocapsule in a wider than deep nodule: 99%
- it is best seen on anterior/posterior margins, perpendicular to the beam
- probably represents normal compressed tissue consistent with a non-infiltrative process
Treatment and prognosis
In all cases of lesions other than those which are absolutely benign, real time review by the radiologist is mandatory. Review of the mammogram is essential when interpretation of an ultrasound is performed. In patients under the age of 30 years, ultrasound is the primary imaging modality. In patients over the age of 40 years, both modalities are performed and interpreted in tandem. Any lesion classified as benign must be benign on both modalities.
Further workup strategy:
- if there is a single malignant feature: consider biopsy
- if there are no malignant features: then look for benign features
- if there are no malignant features or any benign features: indeterminate lesion, consider biopsy
- look at the mammogram
References
- 1. Stavros AT, Thickman D, Rapp CL et-al. Solid breast nodules: use of sonography to distinguish between benign and malignant lesions. Radiology. 1995;196 (1): 123-34. Radiology (abstract) - Pubmed citation
- 2. Rahbar G, Sie AC, Hansen GC et-al. Benign versus malignant solid breast masses: US differentiation. Radiology. 1999;213 (3): 889-94. Radiology (full text) - Pubmed citation
- 3. Cardeñosa G. Clinical breast imaging, a patient focused teaching file. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. (2006) ISBN:0781762677. Read it at Google Books - Find it at Amazon
- 4. Paredes ES. Atlas of mammography. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. (2007) ISBN:0781764335. Read it at Google Books - Find it at Amazon
Related articles: Imaging in practice
- imaging in practice
-
general radiography (adult)
- portable radiography
- chest radiography
- abdominal radiography
-
upper limb radiography
-
shoulder girdle radiography
- scapula series
-
shoulder series
- shoulder (AP view)
- shoulder (internal rotation view)
- shoulder (external rotation view)
- shoulder (superior-inferior axial view)
- shoulder (inferior-superior axial)
- shoulder (West Point view)
- shoulder (Velpeau view)
- shoulder (modified trauma axial view)
- shoulder (supine lateral view)
- shoulder (modified transthoracic supine lateral)
- shoulder (lateral scapula view)
- shoulder (AP glenoid view)
- shoulder (Garth view)
- shoulder (outlet view)
- shoulder (Stryker notch view)
- acromioclavicular joint series
-
clavicle series
- clavicle (AP view)
- clavicle (AP cephalic view)
- clavicle (oblique view)
- sternoclavicular joint series
- arm and forearm radiography
- wrist and hand radiography
- wrist series
- scaphoid series
- hand series
- thumb series
- fingers series
- rheumatology hands series
- bone age (radiograph)
-
shoulder girdle radiography
-
lower limb radiography
- pelvic girdle radiography
- thigh and leg radiography
- ankle and foot radiography
- skull radiography
-
paranasal sinus and facial bone radiography
- facial bones
- nasal bones
- zygomatic arches
- paranasal sinuses
- temporal bones
- dental radiography
- orthopantomography
- mandible
- mandible (PA view)
- mandible (PA axial view)
- mandible (AP axial view)
- mandible (oblique view)
- temporomandibular joints
- temporomandibular joint (AP axial view)
- temporomandibular joint (axiolateral view)
- temporomandibular joint (axiolateral oblique view)
-
spinal radiography
- cervical spine series
-
thoracic spine series
- thoracic spine (AP view)
- thoracic spine (lateral view)
- thoracic spine (oblique view)
- lumbar spine series
- sacrococcygeal radiography
- scoliosis radiography
-
pediatric radiography
- radiographic positioning terminology
- systematic radiographic technical evaluation (mnemonic)
- pediatric immobilization
- foreign body ingestion series (pediatric)
- foreign body inhalation series (pediatric)
- shunt series
- chest radiograph (pediatric)
- abdomen radiograph (pediatric)
-
upper limb radiography (pediatric)
- shoulder series (pediatric)
- pediatric shoulder (AP view)
- pediatric shoulder (lateral view)
- clavicle series (pediatric)
- pediatric clavicle (AP view)
- pediatric clavicle (axial view)
- humerus series (pediatric)
- elbow series (pediatric)
- forearm series (pediatric)
- wrist series (pediatric)
- scaphoid series (pediatric)
- hand series (pediatric)
- thumb series (pediatric)
- finger series (pediatric)
- shoulder series (pediatric)
- lower limb radiography (pediatric)
- pelvis radiograph (pediatric)
- femur series (pediatric)
- pediatric femur (AP view)
- pediatric femur (lateral view)
- leg length view
- knee series (pediatric)
- pediatric knee (AP view)
- pediatric knee (lateral view)
- tibia fibula series (pediatric)
- pediatric tibia fibula (AP view)
- pediatric tibia fibula (lateral view)
- pediatric tibia fibula (oblique view)
- ankle series (pediatric)
- pediatric ankle (AP view)
- pediatric ankle (mortise view)
- pediatric ankle (lateral view)
- foot series (pediatric)
- pediatric foot (DP view)
- pediatric foot (oblique view)
- pediatric foot (lateral view)
- skull radiography (pediatric)
- spine radiography (pediatric)
-
skeletal survey
-
skeletal survey (non-accidental injury)
- torso
- pediatric chest (AP erect view)
- pediatric chest (oblique ribs view)
- pediatric abdomen (AP supine view)
- pediatric spine (whole lateral view)
- upper limb (both sides)
- lower limb (both sides)
- pediatric femur (AP view)
- pediatric knee (lateral view)
- pediatric tibia fibula (AP view)
- pediatric ankle (lateral view)
- pediatric foot (DP view)
- torso
-
skeletal survey (non-accidental injury)
-
CT
- iodinated contrast media
- CT IV contrast media administration
-
CT protocol
- composite
- whole-body CT (protocol)
- CT Chest abdomen-pelvis (protocol)
- CT NCAP (neck, chest, abdomen and pelvis)
- head & neck
- chest
- abdomen and pelvis
- CT abdomen-pelvis (protocol)
- CT abdominal aorta
- CT adrenals (protocol)
- CT cholangiography (protocol)
- CT colonography (protocol)
-
CT enteroclysis (protocol)
-
CT enterography (protocol)
- CT gastrography (protocol)
- CT kidneys, ureters and bladder (protocol)
- CT urography (protocol)
- CT Renal mass (protocol)
- CT angiography of the splanchnic vessels (protocol)
- CT renal split bolus
- CT pancreas (protocol)
- liver
- composite
- barium studies
-
MRI
- cine imaging
-
brain
- screen protocol
- stereotaxis protocol
- tumor protocol
- stroke protocol
- infection protocol
- trauma protocol
- demyelination protocol
- epilepsy protocol
- neurodegenerative protocol
- trigeminal neuralgia protocol
- posterior fossa protocol
- temporal bone/IAM/CPA protocol
- pineal and tectal plate protocol
- pituitary gland protocol
- CSF flow
- angiographic protocols
- MRA
- circle of Willis (COW)
- carotid-vertebral system
- MRV
- MRA
- head and neck
- orbits protocol
- sinonasal tract protocol
- salivary glands protocol
- oropharynx and oral cavity protocol
- suprahyoid neck protocol
- infrahyoid neck protocol
- chest
- abdomen and pelvis
- abdomen
- liver and biliary tree
- liver protocol
- MRCP: cholangiopancreatography
- pancreas protocol
- elastography
- anus and rectum
- uterus and ovaries
- urological
- prostate cancer protocol
- bladder cancer protocol
- kidneys protocol
- musculoskeletal
-
ultrasound
- ultrasound signs
-
obstetric ultrasound
- other
- placenta
-
second trimester
- fetal biometry
- fetal morphology assessment
-
soft markers
- nuchal fold thickness
- ventriculomegaly
- absent nasal bone
- echogenic intracardiac focus
- choroid plexus cysts
- echogenic bowel
- aberrant right subclavian artery
- amnioreduction
- echogenic fetal bowel
- umbilical artery Doppler assessment
- chorionic villus sampling (CVS) and amniocentesis
- nuchal translucency
- failed early pregnancy
- subchorionic hematoma
- multiple gestations
- ectopic pregnancy
-
first trimester and early pregnancy
- gestational sac
- yolk sac
- embryo/fetus
- amnion
- chorion
- Beta-hCG levels
- gynecologic ultrasound
- vascular ultrasound
- carotids
- extremities
- mesenteric vessels
- other
- breast ultrasound
-
musculoskeletal ultrasound
- technique/artifacts
- ultrasound of arthropathies
- skin/soft tissue ultrasound
- lipoma
- parasitic infection
- other
- pediatric musculoskeletal ultrasound
- ankle/foot ultrasound
-
knee ultrasound
- Baker cyst (popliteal cyst)
- infrapatellar bursitis
- hip ultrasound
- hand ultrasound
- wrist ultrasound
- elbow ultrasound
- shoulder ultrasound
- liver ultrasound
- hyperechoic liver lesion
- sonographic halo sign
- ultrasound appearances of liver metastases
- periportal hyperechogenicity
- periportal hypoechogenicity
- generalized increase in hepatic echogenicity
- generalized reduced hepatic echogenicity
- coarsened hepatic echotexture
- starry sky appearance (ultrasound)
- normal hepatic vein Doppler
- hepatic arterial resistive index
- gallbladder ultrasound
- pancreatic ultrasound
- gastrointestinal ultrasound
- renal ultrasound
- bladder ultrasound
-
testicular and scrotal ultrasound
- other
- epididymis
- paratesticular lesions
- bilateral testicular lesion
-
unilateral testicular lesion
- testicular torsion
- orchitis
- testicular rupture
-
germ cell tumor of the testis
- testicular seminoma
-
non seminomatous germ cell tumors
- mixed germ cell tumor
- yolk sac tumor (endodermal sinus tumor)
- embryonal cell carcinoma
- choriocarcinoma
- testicular teratoma
- testicular epidermoid (teratoma with ectodermal elements only)
- burned out testis tumor
- sex cord / stromal tumors of the testis
- prostate ultrasound
- neck and thyroid ultrasound
- echocardiography
- speckle tracking echocardiography
- fetal echocardiography
- contrast-enhanced echocardiography
- epicardial echocardiography
- three dimensional (3D) echocardiography
- transesophageal echocardiography (TEE)
- transthoracic echocardiography (TTE)
- left ventricular systolic and diastolic function
- structure and morphology
- systolic function
- diastolic function
- right ventricular assessment
- right and left atria
- valvular structure and function
- mitral valve
- aortic valve
- pulmonic valve
- tricuspid valve
- hemodynamics
- pericardium
- cardiomyopathies
- congenital heart disease
- great vessels
- pediatric ultrasound
- ultrasound interventions
- ultrasound-guided biopsy
- ultrasound-guided percutaneous drainage
- ultrasound-guided musculoskeletal interventions
- joint injection
- nerve blocks
- ultrasound-guided intravenous cannulation
- contrast-enhanced ultrasound
- physics and imaging modes
- grey-scale (B-mode)
- motion mode (M-mode)
- color flow Doppler (CFD)
-
spectral Doppler
- pulsed wave Doppler (PWD)
- continuous wave Doppler (CWD)
- superb microvascular imaging (SMI)
- tissue Doppler imaging (TDI)
- nuclear medicine
-
radiation therapy
- external beam radiation therapy (EBRT)
- sealed source radiation therapy (brachytherapy)
- unsealed source radiation therapy
-
interventional
- procedure overview
- neck
- thyroid gland
- breast
- chest
- hepatobiliary
- splenic interventions
- gastrointestinal
- urogenital
- bladder
- kidney
- prostate
- musculoskeletal
-
arthrogram
- MR arthrogram
- CT arthrogram
- anesthetic arthrogram
- bone biopsy (CT-guided)
-
arthrogram
- upper limb
- lower limb
-
hip
- hip joint injection (technique)
- greater trochanteric bursa injection
- gluteus minimus/medius tendon calcific tendinopathy barbotage
- iliopsoas tendon bursa injection
- lateral cutaneous femoral nerve of the thigh injection
- piriformis injection
- common hamstrings origin injections
-
knee
- common peroneal (fibular) nerve injection
- knee joint injection
- patella tendon microtenotomy
- quadriceps tendon microtenotomy
- tibial nerve injection
-
ankle
- achilles hydrodilation & microtenotomy
- ankle joint injection
- extensor tendon sheath injection
- flexor tendon sheath injection
- os trigonum injection
- peroneal tendon sheath injection
- subtalar joint injection
- tibial nerve injection
-
foot
- calcaneocuboid joint injection
- metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) injection
- naviculocuneiform joint injection
- plantar fascia microtenotomy
- subtalar joint injection
- talonavicular joint injection
- tarsometatarsal joint (TMTJ) injection
-
hip
- spine
- breast imaging
-
mammography
- breast screening
- breast imaging and the technologist
- forbidden (check) areas in mammography
-
mammography views
- craniocaudal view
- mediolateral oblique view
- additional (supplementary) views
- true lateral view
- lateromedial oblique view
- late mediolateral view
- step oblique views
- spot view
- double spot compression view
- magnification view
- exaggerated craniocaudal (axillary) view
- cleavage view
- tangential views
- caudocranial view
- bullseye CC view
- rolled CC view
- elevated craniocaudal projection
- caudal cranial projection
- 20° oblique projection
- inferomedial superolateral oblique projection
- Eklund technique
- normal breast imaging examples
-
mammography
- digital breast tomosynthesis
- breast ultrasound
- breast ductography
- breast MRI
- breast morphology
- breast intervention