Slipped upper femoral epiphysis
Slipped upper femoral epiphysis (SUFE), also known as a slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE), is a relatively common condition affecting the physis of the proximal femur in adolescents. It is one of commonest hip abnormalities in adolescence and is bilateral in ~20% of cases.
SUFE is more common in boys than girls and more common in Afro-Caribbeans than Caucasians. The age of presentation is somewhat dependent on gender with boys presenting later (10-17 years) than girls (8-15 years) 2. Obesity is a significant risk factor.
Patients present with hip pain progressing to a limp and even leg length discrepancy.
If SUFE is confirmed on an X-ray, the child should be rested, admitted and not allowed to weight-bear.
SUFE is essentially a type I Salter-Harris growth plate injury due to repeated trauma on a background of mechanical and probably hormonal predisposing factors.
Conditions that may predispose to SUFE include:
During growth, there is a widening of the physeal plate which is particularly pronounced during a growth spurt. Also, the axis of the physis alters during growth and moves from being horizontal, to being oblique. As the physis becomes more oblique, shear forces across the growth plate increase and result in an increased risk of fracture and resultant slippage.
In all situations, especially when imaging children, the fewest number of radiographs, with the smallest exposed area is performed. Gonad protection is usually used in pelvic x-rays of children. However, there should always be one radiograph without the lead protection so that the entire pelvis is visualised.
The radiographs that are used will depend on the institution where you work:
- AP and frog-leg: the commonest situation allows assessment of two views
- AP only: a perceived concern about a risk of worsening a slip means that a frog-leg lateral is only performed if the orthopaedic surgeon or radiologist agrees
- frog-leg only: to reduce the dose, only frog-leg lateral is performed because it is this view that is most sensitive and the AP rarely adds diagnostic information
In the pre-slip phase, there is a widening of the growth plate with irregularity and blurring of the physeal edges and demineralisation of the metaphysis. This is followed by the acute slip which is posteromedial. In a chronic slip, the physis becomes sclerotic and the metaphysis widens (coxa magna).
The slip that occurs is posterior and to a lesser extent medial, and therefore is more easily seen on the frog-leg lateral view rather than the AP hip view. Because the epiphysis moves posteriorly, it appears smaller because of projectional factors.
The metaphysis is displaced laterally, and therefore may not overlap posterior lip of the acetabulum as it should normally (loss of triangular sign of Capener) 5.
Alignment of the epiphysis with respect to the femoral metaphysis can be used to grade the degree of slippage: see SUFE grading.
Ultrasound may be performed in the assessment of hip pain. However, it should not be used as a replacement for a pelvic radiograph. Findings are nonspecific and may include hip joint effusion. In some cases, malalignment of the femoral epiphysis and metaphysis may be seen.
CT is a sensitive and an accurate method of measuring the degree of upper femoral epiphyseal tilt and detecting the disease in its early stage. Multiplane reconstruction allows assessment of the relationship of the femoral head to the metaphysis in three planes. However, the dose required for the examination means that it should not be used unless absolutely necessary.
The metaphyseal blanch sign described increases in the density of the proximal metaphysis. It represents an attempt of the healing process that occurs before the visible displacement of the epiphysis.
In the acute stage, marrow oedema results in increased signal on T2-weighted sequences, e.g. STIR. Marrow oedema is non-specific, and while it may indicate early bone changes in SUFE, there are numerous other causes, e.g. infection or tumour.
MRI can be used to examine the contralateral hip which is important because of the high incidence of bilateral slip.
- high signal in epiphysis and metaphysis
- joint effusion
- low signal in oedematous regions
- metaphyseal displacement
Treatment and prognosis
Treatment of unstable SUFE has progressively shifted exclusively towards surgical pinning. Conservative management (e.g. limitation of activity and casting) is no longer recommended.
Treatment of the contralateral hip is more controversial. Bilateral SUFE is relatively common (~20%) and stabilisation of the unstable side can, in fact, precipitate slip on the contralateral side. As such prophylactic pinning is recommended by some 3.
If a significant deformity is present, then osteotomies and even joint replacement may be required.
- long term degenerative osteoarthritis: ~90%
- avascular necrosis of the femoral head (10-15%): increased incidence with the number of attempted reductions and with multiple screws for pinning 3
- chondrolysis (7-10%): acute cartilage necrosis
- limb length discrepancy
When the slip is evident, and no secondary degenerative changes are present, then the diagnosis is usually readily made. Ideally however the diagnosis is made early in which case the differential is that of a painful hip and includes:
- Legg-Calve-Perthes disease
- septic arthritis
- transient synovitis
- developmental dysplasia (late presentation)
Medical student radiology curriculum
- radiology for students
- tests and when to use them
- key findings
- chest pain
- bowel related
- tests and when to use them
- key findings
- upper limb
- lower limb
- major trauma
- joint pain/arthritis
- rheumatoid arthritis
- septic arthritis
- 1. Kaplan P. Musculoskeletal MRI. W B Saunders Co. (2001) ISBN:0721690270. Read it at Google Books - Find it at Amazon
- 2. Boles CA, El-khoury GY. Slipped capital femoral epiphysis. Radiographics. 17 (4): 809-23. Radiographics (abstract) - Pubmed citation
- 3. Seidenberg PH, Bowen JD. The Hip and Pelvis in Sports Medicine and Primary Care. Springer Verlag. (2010) ISBN:1441957871. Read it at Google Books - Find it at Amazon
- 4. Dähnert W. Radiology Review Manual. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. (2007) ISBN:0781766206. Read it at Google Books - Find it at Amazon
- 5. Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research: September 1974 - Volume 103 - Issue - ppg 16-17 Symposium: Tips, Quips And Pearls: The Triangular Sign in the Early Diagnosis of Slipped Capital Femoral Epiphysis. Scham, Stewart M. M.D.