Fracture healing occurs naturally after traumatic bony disruption. This process begins with haemorrhage and progresses through three stages:
This process can be supported by various treatment options with immobilisation a mainstay; inappropriate treatment may result in a variety of complications. Depending on the fracture site, normal healing in adults may take from 3-12 weeks.
Normal fracture healing
For normal fracture healing to occur a number of requirements must be met:
- viability of fragments (i.e. intact blood supply)
- mechanical rest: this can be achieved by not moving and external immobilisation, e.g. cast or internal fixation
- absence of infection
The process of healing is different depending on the configuration of the fracture fragments and can be divided into three main categories:
- spontaneous (indirect/secondary) healing
- contact (angiogenic/primary) healing
- gap healing
Spontaneous (indirect/secondary) healing
This is the most common 'natural' healing process, whereby the fracture ends are placed close to each other (but not apposed), with intervening haematoma and variable displacement and/or angulation.
Though the healing process of a fracture can be divided into various phases, it should rather be understood as a biological continuum. The periosteum, endosteum, and Haversian canals are the sources of pluripotent mesenchymal stem cells that initiate the formation of the healing tissues. The bridging callus seen on radiographs mainly arises from the periosteum.
The process of fracture healing
The fracture haematoma initiates the healing response. Within 48 hours, chemotactic signalling mechanisms attract the inflammatory cells necessary to promote the healing process.
Within 7-14 days, granulation tissue is formed between the fragments, leading to vascularization of the haematoma. On radiographs, there may be increased lucency of the fracture during this stage due to bone resorption.
Progenitor cells within the granulation tissue proliferate and begin to differentiate into fibroblasts and chondroblasts. They produce an extracellular organic matrix of fibrous tissue and cartilage, wherein woven bone is deposited by osteoblasts. This stage usually lasts 4-16 weeks. The newly formed callus is still damageable by shear forces, whereas axial traction and pressure promote matrix formation.
The mesh of woven bone is then replaced by lamellar bone, which is organized parallel to the axis of the bone.
Eventually, remodelling of the bone takes place, restoring its normal cortical structure depending on load distribution. This is an ongoing process that may last for several years. In children, remodelling occurs faster than in adults and may compensate for malunion to some degree.
Average healing times of common fractures
- phalanges: 3 weeks
- metacarpals: 4-6 weeks
- distal radius: 4-6 weeks
- lower arm: 8-10 weeks
- humerus: 6-8 weeks
- femoral neck: 12 weeks
- femoral shaft: 12 weeks
- tibia: 10 weeks
Contact (angiogenic/primary) healing
Contact healing occurs between directly apposed fragments when there is less than 0.1 mm distance and neutralisation of interfragmentary strain. This is the aim of rigid internal fixation. The process is initiated by osteoclasts forming cutting cones that traverse the fracture line at 50-100 µm/day. Capillaries can then occupy the newly-formed cavities and are accompanied by endothelial cells and osteoblast progenitor cells that form lamellar bone from osteons primarily oriented in the axial direction (Haversian remodelling). In stable osteosynthesis, there should be no formation of periosteal callus. Otherwise, this must be regarded as a sign of instability (irritation callus).
If internal fixation leaves a gap of even less than 1 mm between fragments, Haversian remodelling is preceded by the laying down of woven bone scaffolding, after which lamellar bone is deposited perpendicular to the long axis.
Disturbed fracture healing
Normal fracture healing can be disrupted in numerous ways:
- fracture healing takes about twice as long as expected for a specific location
- fracture healing does not occur within 6-9 months
- common sites: scaphoid bone, femoral neck, tibial shaft
- healing in the wrong position
- can be partially compensated for by remodelling of the bone (except for rotational malunion)
- as a rule of the thumb, fixation material should be removed within about 18 months after consolidation of the fracture
- leaving it in place may lead to cortical atrophy and a higher risk of refracturing
Permanent damage to the healing tissue (blastema), typically in the chondral phase. Risk factors include:
- local: insufficient immobilisation, distraction, soft tissue interposition, bone loss, impaired blood supply, soft tissue damage, improper fixation method, infection
- general/systemic: old age, poor nutritional status, drugs and medications, metabolic diseases
Types of pseudarthroses
- rich in callus (elephant foot)
- poor in callus (horse hoof)
- no callus on radiographs, rounded fracture ends
- bone resorption due to infection or impaired blood supply
hypotrophic (non-vital) pseudoarthrosis
- necrotic fragments (increasing fragment density without callus formation)
- missing fragments
- infected pseudoarthrosis: see: osteomyelitis
Treatment options for disturbed healing
- sufficient immobilisation
- electrical stimulation
- bone grafting
- revision of internal fixation
- 1. Rüedi TP, Buckley RE, Moran CG. AO Principles of Fracture Management. (2007) ISBN:3131174420. Read it at Google Books - Find it at Amazon
- 2. Thelen M, Ritter G, Bücheler E. Radiologische Diagnostik der Verletzungen von Knochen und Gelenken., Ein Leitfaden für Radiologen und Traumatologen. Thieme. (1993) ISBN:3137787017. Read it at Google Books - Find it at Amazon
- 3. McRae R, Esser M. Practical Fracture Treatment. Churchill Livingstone. (2008) ISBN:1455725234. Read it at Google Books - Find it at Amazon
- 4. Islam O, Soboleski D, Symons S et-al. Development and duration of radiographic signs of bone healing in children. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2000;175 (1): 75-8. doi:10.2214/ajr.175.1.1750075 - Pubmed citation