Clear cell chondrosarcoma
Citation, DOI & article data
Clear cell chondrosarcomas are low-grade malignant chondrogenic bone neoplasms of the epiphysis. They got their name from the presence of clear cell chondrocytes which contain abundant vacuolated cytoplasm due to the presence of glycogen.
Clear cell chondrosarcomas make up around 2% of all chondrosarcomas 1,2 and are usually seen in the 3rd to 5th decade even though they have been reported in an age range of 12-84 years 1. Men are almost three times as often affected as women 1.
The diagnosis of clear cell chondrosarcomas is mainly based on typical pathology 1.
Diagnostic criteria according to the WHO classification of soft tissue and bone tumors (5thedition) 1:
Essential criteria are 1:
- clear cells with abundant cytoplasm and central nuclei
- woven bone and osteoclastic giant cells
An epiphyseal location of the tumor is a desirable criterion 1.
Clinically, clear cell sarcomas most commonly present with pain. Symptoms persist for an average duration of one year or up to 5 years, suggesting slow growth of the lesion 1.
Complications include 2,3:
- pathological fractures
- tumor recurrence
- metastases to lung and bone (in exceptional cases)
Clear cell chondrosarcomas are low-grade malignant cartilaginous bone neoplasms often found in the epiphyses and characterized by the presence of lobules of clear cells that contain an abundant clear or mildly eosinophilic cytoplasm with centrally placed nuclei 1-3.
The etiology of clear cell chondrosarcomas is not known 1.
The lesion is most often in an epi-metaphyseal location of long tubular bones 1-4 (in contradistinction to conventional chondrosarcoma, which is usually metaphyseal-diaphyseal). Yet, they have been described in several locations of the skeleton including the skull, spine, ribs, hands and feet 1-4
- proximal femur: 55-60% (commonest)
- proximal humerus: 10-15%
Grossly clear cell chondrosarcomas usually contain soft gritty material with features of hyaline cartilage, the latter can be also focal or absent 1.
Histologically clear cell chondrosarcomas are characterized by the following 1-4:
- lobules of cells with abundant clear or mildly eosinophilic cytoplasm
- distinct cytoplasmic membranes
- large round nuclei with prominent central nucleoli
- only mild atypia, rare mitoses
- reactive (woven) bone formation
- intermingled osteoclastic giant cells
- calcified or ossified hyaline cartilage
- areas of low-grade chondrosarcoma might be present
- possible aneurysmal bone cyst-like changes
Clear cell chondrosarcomas are usually well-defined osteolytic lesions often found in the epi-metaphysis of the proximal femur or humerus 1-3. A diaphyseal extension is rare 7. They might have matrix mineralization, thin sclerotic borders or cystic changes 2-4,7.
Lesions in the proximal humerus usually appear more aggressive than in other long bones 2,7.
Lesions in the axial skeleton are typically more expansive, lack mineralization and tend to show soft tissue extension more often than their counterparts in the long bones 2.
On radiographs, clear cell chondrosarcomas are predominantly radiolucent and expansile 2,3,5-7:
- endosteal irregularity is not infrequent
- a periosteal reaction is usually absent
- soft tissue extension and cortical break are usually seen only if a pathologic fracture occurs
- a calcified matrix might be present
- a peripheral sclerotic rim is common (simulating a benign lesion)
- variable transition zone
They are usually classified as grade 1A or 1B on the Lodwick classification of lytic bone lesions 6.
Clear cell chondrosarcomas may appear as solitary lucent bone lesions on CT 2.
Matrix mineralization with a chondroid matrix as well as concerning features such as cortical involvement and soft tissue extension can be more readily depicted 2.
On MRI clear cell chondrosarcomas are mostly characterized as low T1/high T2 bone lesions with signal heterogeneity due to matrix mineralization or intralesional hemorrhage 2,7.
Surrounding perilesional bone marrow edema is absent or minimal in most cases 2,7.
Typically reported signal characteristics on MR imaging include 1,2,5-7:
- T1: low signal intensity
- T2: moderate to high signal intensity
- T1 C+ (Gd): diffuse or heterogeneous enhancement
The radiological report should include a description of the following 8:
- location and size
- tumor margins and transition zone
- relation to the growth plate and articular surface
- cystic and solid tumor components
- fluid-fluid levels suggesting aneurysmal bone cyst-like changes
- additional features
On CT and MRI the lesion should be categorized as Bone-RADS 4 unless histology has been already obtained 8.
Treatment and prognosis
Clear cell chondrosarcomas are relatively slow-growing. The treatment of choice is en bloc resection, which is usually curative with clear margins 1,2,9, whereas marginal excision and curettage are associated with high recurrence rates 1,2. Bone and lung metastases occur in 15-20% 1,9, and the overall mortality is about 15% 1,6, therefore surveillance of 10 years or longer has been advocated 9.
History and etymology
Clear cell chondrosarcomas were first described by the American pathologist K.Krishnan Unni in 1976 2-5,10.
The differential includes lesions with a predilection for the epiphysis (see differential for an epiphyseal lesion). Specific lesions that need to be considered include the following 1:
- chondroblastoma: a particular feature of clear cell chondrosarcomas is a predilection for the epiphysis, in which case they mimic chondroblastomas; distinguishing between the two can be difficult (see chondroblastoma vs. clear cell chondrosarcoma)
- lytic bone metastases (especially from clear cell renal cell carcinoma)
- giant cell tumor of bone
- multiple myeloma
- benign notochordal cell tumor
- 1. WHO Classification of Tumours Editorial Board. WHO Classification of Tumours, 5th Edition. Soft Tissue and Bone Tumours. (2020) ISBN: 9789283245025 - IARC Publications
- 2. Collins M, Koyama T, Swee R, Inwards C. Clear Cell Chondrosarcoma: Radiographic, Computed Tomographic, and Magnetic Resonance Findings in 34 Patients with Pathologic Correlation. Skeletal Radiol. 2003;32(12):687-94. doi:10.1007/s00256-003-0668-3 - Pubmed
- 3. Engels C, Werner M, Delling G. [Clear-Cell Chondrosarcoma]. Pathologe. 2000;21(6):449-55. doi:10.1007/s002920000417 - Pubmed
- 4. Present D, Bacchini P, Pignatti G, Picci P, Bertoni F, Campanacci M. Clear Cell Chondrosarcoma of Bone. A Report of 8 Cases. Skeletal Radiol. 1991;20(3):187-91. doi:10.1007/BF00241664 - Pubmed
- 5. Ayoub K, Grimer R, Carter S, Mangham D, Davies A, Tillman R. Clear Cell Chondrosarcoma of Bone. Sarcoma. 1999;3(2):115-9. doi:10.1080/13577149977749 - Pubmed
- 6. Kaim A, Hügli R, Bonél H, Jundt G. Chondroblastoma and Clear Cell Chondrosarcoma: Radiological and MRI Characteristics with Histopathological Correlation. Skeletal Radiol. 2002;31(2):88-95. doi:10.1007/s00256-001-0450-3 - Pubmed
- 7. Douis H & Saifuddin A. The Imaging of Cartilaginous Bone Tumours. II. Chondrosarcoma. Skeletal Radiol. 2013;42(5):611-26. doi:10.1007/s00256-012-1521-3 - Pubmed
- 8. Chang C, Garner H, Ahlawat S et al. Society of Skeletal Radiology- White Paper. Guidelines for the Diagnostic Management of Incidental Solitary Bone Lesions on CT and MRI in Adults: Bone Reporting and Data System (Bone-RADS). Skeletal Radiol. 2022. doi:10.1007/s00256-022-04022-8 - Pubmed
- 9. Klein A, Tauscher F, Birkenmaier C et al. Clear Cell Chondrosarcoma is an Underestimated Tumor: Report of 7 Cases and Meta-Analysis of the Literature. J Bone Oncol. 2019;19:100267. doi:10.1016/j.jbo.2019.100267 - Pubmed
- 10. Unni K, Dahlin D, Beabout J, Sim F. Chondrosarcoma: Clear-Cell Variant. A Report of Sixteen Cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1976;58(5):676-83. - Pubmed
- 11. Itälä A, Leerapun T, Inwards C, Collins M, Scully S. An Institutional Review of Clear Cell Chondrosarcoma. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2005;440(&NA;):209-12. doi:10.1097/01.blo.0000174686.70003.e0 - Pubmed
- 12. Zhang Y, Alagic Z, Tani E, Skorpil M, Tsagkozis P, Haglund F. Clear-Cell Chondrosarcomas: Fine-Needle Aspiration Cytology, Radiological Findings, and Patient Demographics of a Rare Entity. Diagn Cytopathol. 2021;49(1):46-53. doi:10.1002/dc.24582 - Pubmed
- 13. Murphey M, Walker E, Wilson A, Kransdorf M, Temple H, Gannon F. From the Archives of the AFIP: Imaging of Primary Chondrosarcoma: Radiologic-Pathologic Correlation. Radiographics. 2003;23(5):1245-78. doi:10.1148/rg.235035134 - Pubmed
- 14. Varma D, Ayala A, Carrasco C, Guo S, Kumar R, Edeiken J. Chondrosarcoma: MR Imaging with Pathologic Correlation. Radiographics. 1992;12(4):687-704. doi:10.1148/radiographics.12.4.1636034 - Pubmed